Which do yall think is bigger (My PBs)

The first one is significantly fatter but the second one longer. For those saying this isn’t ‘proper carp care’ these were stocked into a neighbors small backyard pond, not even sure how they got this big. But anyway they did, and they were stocked over 10 years ago and no longer clean up the vegetation and they want to stock it with some new ones. They’ve asked me and my friends to remove these old carp, and it’s a lot of fun. If it were up to me, I would keep these as game fish but it’s not my land and for some extra cash and lots of fun I don’t mind doing it so please don’t comment on the ‘carp care’ they are going in their compost bin anyway.